Please Wait...

A jacobian-based method to assess changes in cortical thickness Application to ADNI data and comparison with longitudinal freesurfer

J. Schaerer, F. Roche, L. Bracoud, A. Coste, C. Joly, J. Oh, B. Belaroussi, J. Suhy
BioClinica, Lyon, France and Newark, CA, USA - email:


Brain cortical thickness measured with MRI shows ability to discriminate between Normal Controls (NC), Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) and AD subjects.

Longitudinal analysis allows assessing disease progression and treatment efficacy in the context of clinical trials.

Several automated methods have been proposed. The aim of this work is to compare a Jacobian-based method to FreeSurfer Longitudinal, using ADNI-1 data.


Cortical thickness measurements were performed on the 3D T1-weighted sequences of 619 subjects' MRI scans with 3 follow-ups, Month 6, Month 12 and Month 24 (171 NC, 190 MCI who did not convert to AD within 24 months, 144 MCI who converted and 114 AD) from the ADNI database (

Image Analysis
The proposed method uses the Jacobian map to compute longitudinal change in cortical thickness [1].

Each pair of scans is pre-processed as follows (Figure 1 & 2): N3-correction, registration in a mid-way space to avoid bias towards either timepoint and deformation field computation using a symmetric log-demons registration algorithm with a robust cross-correlation metric to compute the Jacobian map [2-3].

Baseline cortical thickness is assessed by solving Laplace's equation, building the set of paths between the inner and outer cortical surfaces and deriving the average thickness from them.

On follow-ups, thickness is obtained by weighting path lengths with the Jacobian map.

Statistical Analysis

This technique was quantitatively compared to FreeSurfer Longitudinal v4.4

( using Pearson's correlation.

Their respective ability to discriminate between ADNI groups was assessed by ROC analysis.

Their potential to detect treatment effect was assessed by computing effect size.

Finally, the temporal regularity of each measurement was assessed by computing the average R² from per-patient linear regressions.

Jacobian-based results were strongly correlated (r=0.73, p<0.001) to FreeSurfer Longitudinal.

ROC analysis of change in cortical thickness showed improved group separation at each timepoint, improved temporal regularity and effect size compared to FreeSurfer Longitudinal (see Figure 2 and Tables 1 & 2).

A fully automated pipeline for robust calculation of longitudinal changes in cortical thickness was proposed.

This method provided results consistent with FreeSurfer Longitudinal, outperforming the latter in terms of group separation, temporal regularity and effect size.

Further testing will have to be completed, including test/retest, to validate its use for clinical trials.

Yang Li, Yaping Wang, Zhong Xue, Feng Shi, Weili Lin, and Dinggang Shen, Consistent 4D cortical thickness measurement for longitudinal neuroimaging study, MICCAI 2010.

Vercauteren et al., Symmetric log-domain diffeomorphic Registration: a demons-based approach, MICCAI 2008

[3] Istace et al., Comparison of Boundary Shift Integral (BSI) ans Tensor Based Morphometry (TBM) to assess volume changes on whole brain and lateral ventricles - Application to study CN156-018, CTAD 2013


Leader in Clinical Trial
Management Solutions

Successful clinical trials require the ability to see key details and uncover hidden insights. Bioclinica utilizes science and technology to bring clarity to clinical trials, helping companies to develop new life-improving therapies more efficiently and safely.

No change order fees for new clients with our #RTSM platform means fewer hurdles as you race to study start. Ready…
Bioclinica (15 hours ago)
Check out the first post in our CEO David Herron's new blog to find out what makes him a mission-driven leader…
Bioclinica (2 weeks ago)
Bioclinica is seeking medical writers with 1-2 years’ experience, imaging research preferred. Great opportunity to…
Bioclinica (2 weeks ago)
Learn more about how your skills can make a difference at Bioclinica! #Bioclinica #clinicaltrials #clinicalresearch…
Bioclinica (2 weeks ago)
Read our CEO’s thoughts on Bioclinica’s mission-driven growth agenda. #bioclinica…
Bioclinica (2 weeks ago)
Changes are a fact of life - and of #clinicaltrial design. But that doesn't mean planning and budgeting for your tr…
Bioclinica (3 weeks ago)